Who stole the cookie from the cookie jar? Alex stole the cookie from the cookie jar. Who? Me? Yes, you. Couldn't have been then. Then who? Lucas stole the cookie from the cookie jar. Who? Me? <v ->Yes. You. </v> Couldn't have been. Then who? Jacob stole the cookie from the cookie jar. Who? Me? Yes, you. Couldn't have been. Then who? Andeep stole the cookie from the cookie jar. Who? Me? Yes, you. Couldn't have been. Then who? Izzy stole the cookie from.